Tobacco 2.0 When Money Buys the Truth & the Outcome
Where
Talks
ShmooCon 2024
Duration
20 min
Explores how big tech uses money and influence to suppress research, and how whistleblowers can respond.
Summary
The session opens with the chief executive of a nonprofit that supports public interest whistleblowers, and a journalism professor who says she was pushed out of her university research role after obtaining internal Facebook documents. They frame the problem as a tobacco-style playbook: hiding harms, building favorable public narratives, and drowning out independent research with money and influence.
The middle of the talk covers the professor's experience of losing research funding and staff after her planned publication of those documents drew pressure from a platform with many alumni and donors at her institution. The nonprofit explains how it selects cases, prioritizing motive, public interest and potential reach, and what support it gives whistleblowers, including legal help, security measures, therapy and practical needs. They also describe the predictable retaliation tactics, such as discrediting the person, isolating them, and redirecting attention away from the facts.
The closing turns to wider stakes, including a platform's decision to restrict news access in Canada and the resulting gap that disinformation can fill. The speakers encourage people with technical and policy skills to find better ways to distribute reliable news and reduce platform dominance over information. For practitioners, the main takeaway is to get legal advice before acting, plan for retaliation, and treat corporate influence over independent research as a real risk to the public.
Related talks
Talks·52 min
Adam Klasfeld · Sahil Lavingia
A journalist questions a former DOGE engineer about his time at the VA, contract review work, and the government's software gaps.
Talks·1 hr 48 min
Takes audience questions to the Electronic Frontier Foundation about digital rights and online privacy.
Talks·54 min
Alessandro Polidoro
Traces a European legal campaign against porn platforms under data and platform rules, alongside research on image-based sexual abuse.


